21 Nov 2011

FUKUSHIMA-LIKE INCIDENT “NOT CONCEIVABLE” HERE, so says a 15 member “Central Experts Panel”(The Panel) which constitutes the “Center to interact with the local people in and around the Kudankulam Nuclear Power Project(KKNPP)”, has released its findings regarding design safety aspects of the Kudankulam NPPs, during a  presentation before the Nominees ? of the State government, and the concerned Tirunelvely local representatives, at the office of the Tirunelveli Collectorate on 18 Nov 2011. The Panel has concluded that a Fukushima-type accident, is not conceivable at the Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant (NPP).  The 39 page text of the presentation was released to the media on 19 Nov 2011.

IN RESPONSE TO CONCERNS OF RESIDENTS The Panel referred to the reports of concerns/apprehensions among the local residents on the safety of the plant in the wake of the Fukushima Dai No.1 incident in Japan on 12 Mar 2011. The Panel noted that preparatory work for an off-site emergency exercise(a safety requirement per the regulations of the Indian Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) prior to loading nuclear fuel, seemed to have further aggravated the concerns /apprehensions of the local, and nearby people. The Panel report stated:

CAUSE OF FUKUSHIMA’S FAILURES. A spokesman for The Panel, said that the root cause of the accident at Fukushima was complete loss of power supply to units 1 to 4 as a result of flooding at the site caused by the tsunami. While units 1, 2 and 3 were shut down automatically (unit 4 was already in shutdown state, but with its fuel unloaded in the Spent Fuel Pool). The cooling of their core could not be maintained in the absence of power supply, resulting in three reactor meltdowns.

TSUNAMI RULED-OUT AS A CONCERN The Panel examined the design of the KKNPP in this respect and found “all safety related structures, systems and components of KKNPP are located well above the maximum flooding that can cover the site from all possible causes including tsunami; therefore, a total loss of power supply at KKNPP, was not possible”.


1. The global trend on the use of nuclear energy for power generation (everybody else is doing it, (WAS – IS MORE LIKE IT!)

2. Safety features of the KKNPP,

3. Environmental impact assessment has been done in all plants in the country, and it is safe.

4. Local employment opportunities (to “sweeten the pot for local people)

5. Nuclear waste management. A KEY ISSUE WITHOUT AN ANSWER 

6. Tsunami warning systems available, emergency preparedness.

7. Noise pollution.

8. PASSIVE HEAT REMOVAL AT THE KKNPP was provided which  could effectively cool a reactor under the condition of “total loss of electric power” – NOT LIKELY

FIVE(5) MAIN CONCERNS WERE NOT ADDRESSED by The Panel. Five(5) issues mentioned in the memorandum submitted by two Official Representatives of the protesting Tirunelvely region people (where the Kundankulam NPPs are) at the previous meeting on 08 Nov 2011, were not addressed by the report; they are:

1. Terms of the Inter-governmental agreement between Russia and India

2. impact on bilateral relations between Indian and Russian governments

3. Russian versus Indian liability in the event of NPP malfunction or worse.

4. Nuclear Suppliers Group-related issues.

5. Possibility of the intention to set-up a nuclear weapon facility at the Kudankulam NPP

EVIDENTLY THE POWERS OF “B” ARE ALL SATISFIED: They have been for nearly 10 years right up to the highest Indian governmental levels; After Fukushima however, they find themselves defending their policies to the people India;  Accordingly,  The Panel “hung their hat” on the Indian Atomic Energy Review Board, which supposedly gave an in-depth review of the KKNPP.  The “commissioning program” was also progressively reviewed by the board.  That is the final AERB o.k. to “go critical” – UGH!

Note: Above article was printed by:

And re-written for clarity to Western readers.



This article is a follow-up to: INDIA – A NEW COLONY OF RUSSIA? ITS THIRST FOR ENERGY COULD MAKE IT SO. –  Dated 21 Oct 2011  Published here.

SUPPOSEDLY THE INDIAN AERBs (Indian Version of the American NRC) gave the issue an extensive review which supposedly provided assurance of the ROBUSTNESS of the DESIGN SAFETY, and construction of KKNPP. (THOSE ARE CAREFULLY CHOSEN WORDS USED BY ALL NPP PROPONENTS…UNTIL THE STUFF HITS THE FAN!); Then, they say: “who could have imagined that ? !” – THAT IS A PROBLEM!  

ANOTHER PROBLEM IS NPP BUILDERS LIE A LOT!, and there is no reason to believe Russia is different.  I have had NPP proponents lie to me in public, and tell fiction, rather than truth to assuage the innocent public (Here, in San Antonio, Texas-USA, we stopped them cold in 2010). They will stop at nothing to get a “piece of the pie” (Billion of money).  Thus is their corrupt and corrupting influence.  When confronted with specific concerns/issues (as they were at Tirunelvely) they give “non-answers”( non-sequitur) as if unfazed.

NO RESPONSE GIVEN TO INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS. To the concern/chagrin of the Indian Central Government, the people of Tirunelvely, and many others all over India, are also concerned with “intellectual property rights”; Rightly so, these are the key to “Follow-on Procurement” of spare parts and Refueling of the power plants for life (40 to 60 years); As such, they are the key to long term satisfaction, and denote honesty in negotiation; THOSE COUNTRIES NOT WILLING TO GRANT THEM, HAVE LONG TERM AMBITIONS TO GET YOU BY THE PARTS! You know what I mean, don‘t you? DO YOU THINK RUSSIA WILL GRANT THEM FREELY?  I don’t think so. 

PASSIVE REACTOR COOLING SYSTEMS – A LIE ?  Since the Fukushima triple NPP meltdowns, NPP  proponents try to defend their plants, and plans for new ones, by talking about futuristic, supposedly new/great passive cooling systems; However, that is mostly propaganda aimed at selling the un-sellable to a now knowledgeable public. In the case of Kundankulum, Russian NPPs designed about 10 years ago(or more) are highly unlikely to incorporate “passive cooling systems”. Such futuristic systems are a selling point for Gen III+ reactors;  However, to my knowledge these are not yet in use anywhere in the world. “We are go’ana” incorporate them is not good enough! Check them out!

TODAY, NPP OPERATIONAL SAFETY IS NO LONGER THE MAIN ISSUE. The real problem is the huge worldwide accumulation of “Spent Fuel”(Transuranics) – highly toxic nuclear waste with very long decay rates, and NO PLACE TO SAFELY STORE THEM FOR ETERNITY.  Kundankulum(and every other NPP) in the world will only serve to aggravate the problem.  Again no answers provided by The Panel.



November 21, 2011 at 12:36 AM
  • November 22, 2011 at 8:36 PMsupra ns

    Advantageously, the advice is actually the sweetest on this merited topic.

  • November 22, 2011 at 10:26 PMgaucho

    Great to find such great blog, I really like it. You are the best!

  • November 30, 2011 at 1:34 AMAnonymous

    Hi my relative! I want to say that this article is awesome, It is well written, and covers almost all important facts. I’d like to see more posts like this one.

  • November 30, 2011 at 2:09 AMTyson F. Gautreaux

    Greetings, great Website! This article has really helped.

  • December 1, 2011 at 3:00 PMCrandall

    I have been exploring for while for high-quality articles or weblog posts like this. Studying this info, I’m happy to say that I have discovered exactly what I needed. I will certainly make sure not to forget this website, and give it a frequent read.

  • December 2, 2011 at 7:41 AMwaterig

    Just wish to say your article is surprising. The clarity of your publish is simply spectacular, and one could think you are a professional in this subject. Allow me to seize your RSS feed to keep updated with upcoming posts. Thanks a million, and please carry on the gratifying work.
    REPLY: Thanks a lot. I am scientifically and technically steeped, and my background includes aero-systems engineering which makes it easier to grasp, and see clearly what some “experts” do not.

  • December 5, 2011 at 7:37 PMSungate

    I like the helpful info your articles provide. I will bookmark your weblog, and check regularly. I’m sure to learn something new here! – Good luck!

  • December 6, 2011 at 4:55 PMJob

    Wow, fantastic weblog format! How long have you been blogging ? you make running a blog look easy. The full glance of your website is excellent, let alone the content material!
    REPLY: Thank you for your kind remarks. I have been blogging for about four(4) years, and have often thought those who follow their calling: “make it look easy”; even when it involves a lot of work.

  • December 7, 2011 at 2:05 AMVista

    Helpful information. Lucky me I found your website by accident, and I am stunned why this coincidence did not came about in advance! I bookmarked it.

  • December 7, 2011 at 5:08 AMReatha Stanwick

    I’d like to thank you for the effort you put into writing this site. I’m hoping for the same high-grade website posts from you in the days to come. Your creative writing ability has encouraged me to get my own site; Actually, blogging is spreading its wings easily. Your write-up is a excellent example of it.

    REPLY: Glad to hear it !

  • December 9, 2011 at 6:56 AMBrunilda Woodhead

    I’d have to study with you here, which is not something I usually do! I do enjoy studying a post that can make folks think.

  • December 10, 2011 at 10:14 AMSheladia

    I will immediately grasp your rss feed as I can not to find your e-mail subscription, hyperlink or newsletter service. Do you have any? I would ike to subscribe. Thanks.

    REPLY: To subscribe, go to Google Reader (bottom left hand corner) and click on this website. Thanks to you!

  • December 10, 2011 at 5:56 PMMorgan

    I love to share this posting with the readers on my site. Thanks for sharing!
    REPLY: Merry Christmas to all !

  • December 11, 2011 at 3:13 AMMike

    Useful information. Fortunately, I discovered your web site by accident, and I’m stunned that such information was not available earlier. I’ve bookmarked it.

    REPLY: Good! – Let’s just say Blogs can be more incisive and truthfull than the regular press at “telling it like it is”

  • December 11, 2011 at 10:16 AMAnonymous

    I feel that is one of the most important articles for me, and I am satisfied studying your article. Just want to comment that the site taste is ideal, and the articles truly nice: D. Good publish! Cheers.

  • December 11, 2011 at 11:14 AMSilver

    Relatively radical; However, I am sorry but I do not subscribe to your whole strategy, all be it radical none the less. It seems to us that your comments are generally not entirely validated, and in simple fact that you are yourself not really totally convinced of the point. In any event I did enjoy examining it.

  • December 11, 2011 at 8:05 PMBritany

    “It’s hugely ironic that as Russia gets more liberal and allows protests that even a decade ago would have been unthinkable, Britain’s going in the other direction. Protests of all kinds are going to be banned during the period of the Olympics. Honestly, the UK gets more like old-school Russia every day.”

    REPLY: I found your concern so disturbing that I wrote a new ARTICLE in response at: (ARTICLES are listed on column at right side-bottom of page)

  • December 12, 2011 at 5:33 PMSydney Mahaley

    I wrote just the other day how proud I was of the Governor for standing up for those in pain and suffering from a myriad of illness. Even when our other so called “representatives” seem to lack understanding or compassion for the very people who put them in office. I was overcome with a sincere ” wow he cares!” he heard our voices, he heard the cries, and sees our suffering: However, it seems it is just not enough pain and suffering to move him to stand up against such cruelty. What a shame, he will leave office with a legacy of betraying the sick, the hurting and the dying.

    REPLY: We don’t know where this happened. Problem is it could be in any one of so many such places. Politicians and Lawyers, Hambug!

  • December 14, 2011 at 12:35 AMAnonymous

    Wonderful work! This is precisely the sort of stuff that should be distributed in the world wide web. Shame on the people who program the search engines for not displaying it near the top rated!

    REPLY: I agree! Hear that Google software engineers ? Wake up to reality!

  • December 15, 2011 at 10:25 AMAnonymous

    I Just had to say, Many thanks. Staying in North East Scotland, it’s great to find a great websitelike yours; especially with useful entries like the one above. Many thanks and keep up the good work.

  • Newer Comments »

Commenting is closed